I read Steven Pinker, so of course I can't resist playing around with syllables.
So this thread is a hobby/pastime thread.
The attached ZIP file contains a Word2003 template whose Test macro populates columns 2 and 3 of a table with the number of syllables in the word in column 1, (columns 2 & 3 because I have two methods).
In column 4 is the number of syllables *I* think it should be based on my understanding of the English (UK, Australia, Canada) language.
I'm not immediately interested in "fixing" the RegExp but am curious - before we start - whether language students agree with me on those words which I think are nor properly analyzed by one or both of the regexps.
In other words, before I criticize the RegExp, is my understanding of the English language up to scratch?
Here's where I disagree with the results of the RegExps.
The number to the right is the number of syllables *I* think the word has.
torontonians 5
fashionable 4
remarkable 4
annoying 3
unable 3
mckenzie 3
patios 3
sarcasm 3
supplier 3
toastier 3
usual 3
cancelled 2
depressed 2
forecast 2
likely 2
shuttered 2
being 2
crying 2
drizzle 2
little 2
single 2
isn’t 2
it’d 2
closed 1
dimes 1
games 1
lines 1
moved 1
ones 1
passed 1
rained 1
sales 1
stacked 1
states 1
royal 1
Syllables & Regular Expressions
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 15619
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Syllables & Regular Expressions
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
There's nothing heavier than an empty water bottle
-
- StarLounger
- Posts: 79
- Joined: 08 Feb 2010, 21:48
- Location: Wellington, New Zealand
Re: Syllables & Regular Expressions
Chris
Interesting hobby!
The following are websites that count syllables:
http://www.wordcalc.com/
http://www.syllablecount.com/
http://www.howmanysyllables.com/
I tested some of the words in your list using these. According to them, some of the time your understanding is correct and some of the time it's not.
By the way, is "torontonians" a real word, or did you just make that up? It doesn't really roll off the tongue - or not with a New Zealand accent anyway.
William
Interesting hobby!
The following are websites that count syllables:
http://www.wordcalc.com/
http://www.syllablecount.com/
http://www.howmanysyllables.com/
I tested some of the words in your list using these. According to them, some of the time your understanding is correct and some of the time it's not.
By the way, is "torontonians" a real word, or did you just make that up? It doesn't really roll off the tongue - or not with a New Zealand accent anyway.
William
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 15619
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Re: Syllables & Regular Expressions
I got it from The Toronto Star this afternoon.William wrote:Chris, Interesting hobby!
Hi William,
Don't blame me; blame Steven Pinker!
By the way, is "torontonians" a real word, or did you just make that up?
Yes, we Torontonians often describe ourselves as Torontonians.
I believe that "5" is correct, as in To-ron-ton-i-ans.
I'd split Thes-pi-ans the same way.
Vowels are those sounds that give the muscles of the mouth etc time to adopt their new position, spacers in time, if you will, so the penultimate i is really pronounced ee, and the a is more like a ya, using the y as an almost-consonant.
Pinker explains it way better than can I.
P.S. What do New Zealanders call Wel-ling-ton-i-ans?
There's nothing heavier than an empty water bottle
-
- 4StarLounger
- Posts: 508
- Joined: 17 Dec 2010, 03:14
Re: Syllables & Regular Expressions
All sorts of things - some of which don't bear repetition.ChrisGreaves wrote:What do New Zealanders call Wel-ling-ton-i-ans?
Paul Edstein
[Fmr MS MVP - Word]
[Fmr MS MVP - Word]
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 15619
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Re: Syllables & Regular Expressions
macropod wrote:some of which don't bear repetition.
There's nothing heavier than an empty water bottle
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 15619
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Re: Syllables & Regular Expressions
Here's another part of the problem for students of syllables, carefully calculated to trip up some Regular Expressions:ChrisGreaves wrote:I read Steven Pinker,
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
There's nothing heavier than an empty water bottle
-
- StarLounger
- Posts: 79
- Joined: 08 Feb 2010, 21:48
- Location: Wellington, New Zealand
Re: Syllables & Regular Expressions
Hmmm. I suspect that we won't see a movie based on a Steven Pinker book anytime soon.
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 15619
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Re: Syllables & Regular Expressions
Ha! William, you're right.William wrote:Hmmm. I suspect that we won't see a movie based on a Steven Pinker book anytime soon.
There's nothing heavier than an empty water bottle
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 15619
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Re: Syllables & Regular Expressions
While you're waiting, would you settle for a Word VBA macro?William wrote:Hmmm. I suspect that we won't see a movie based on a Steven Pinker book anytime soon.
Code: Select all
''' Code based on page 196 of "The language Instinct" by Steven Pinker ISBN 0-06-095833-2
Public Const sngcPP As Single = 0.3
Public Const sngcDET As Single = 0.3
Sub TESTS()
MsgBox S
End Sub
Function S() As String
S = NP & VP
End Function
Function NP() As String
NP = det & N & PP
End Function
Function VP() As String
VP = V & NP & PP
End Function
Function PP() As String
If Rnd() < sngcPP Then
PP = P & NP
Else
End If
End Function
Function N() As String
N = strRand(",boy,girl,dog,cat,ice cream,candy,hotdogs")
End Function
Function V() As String
V = strRand(",eats,likes,bites")
End Function
Function P() As String
P = strRand(",with,in,near")
End Function
Function det() As String
If Rnd() < sngcDET Then
det = strRand(",a,the,one")
Else
End If
End Function
Function strRand(ByVal strDictionary) As String
''' Return a random string from the dictionary
Dim strDelimiter
strDelimiter = Left(strDictionary, 1)
strDictionary = Right(strDictionary, Len(strDictionary) - 1)
Dim lngWords As Long
lngWords = Len(strDictionary) - Len(Replace(strDictionary, strDelimiter, ""))
lngWords = Rnd() * lngWords
strRand = " " & Split(strDictionary, strDelimiter)(lngWords)
'Sub TESTstrRand()
' Debug.Print strRand(",with,in,near")
'End Sub
End Function
There's nothing heavier than an empty water bottle